The perils of market-timing and over-confidence

 

One of the cruellest tricks investors can play on themselves is to overrate their own abilities.

Chris Cuffe writes in a recent issue of his Cuffelinks investment newsletter that academics have named this overestimation of abilities and underestimation of weaknesses as "illusory superiority".
The over-ranking one's ability extends, of course, to many areas of our lives. For instance, Cuffe points to US surveys showing that more than 90 per cent of drivers rank their driving skills in the top 50 per cent.

  

 

As Cuffe says, one of the investment areas where investors display over-confidence in their abilities is in making short-term adjustments – commonly called tactical asset allocation (TAA) – to the long-term asset allocations of their portfolios.

"TAA is market-timing with a fancier name," he writes, "and usually involves switching from equities to defensive assets and vice versa in anticipation of a major stock market move. Unfortunately, nobody rings a bell to tell when this is about to happen..."

Cuffe has undertaken an interesting exercise which shows how different asset classes have performed in the past. (The tool enables investors to specify the asset allocation and the investment period.)

He looked at how a portfolio with a classic 70/30 asset allocation – 70 per cent in growth assets – would have performed in the 10 years from January 1, 2004 to December 31, 2013. His selected asset allocation was Australian shares (35 per cent), international shares – $A unhedged (25 per cent), Australian property – listed REITs (10 per cent), cash (5 per cent), Australian bonds (15 per cent) and international bonds (10 per cent).

Assuming no transaction costs or tax in order simplify the examples, $1,000 invested at the beginning of the period and invested in accordance with this 70/30 asset allocation would have grown to $1,962 in 10 years – a compound average growth of 6.98 per cent a year. This is on the assumption that the portfolio was not rebalanced each year.

However if the portfolio were rebalanced annually to return to its initial asset allocation, the $1,000 would have grown to $2,094 over the 10 years – a compound average annual return of 7.6 per cent.

Cuffe notes that large public super funds may allow a small range of adjustments either side of their percentage target allocation to each asset class (for their premixed portfolios such as balanced) but few would provide for major adjustments.

In his article, Cuffe also uses Vanguard's Asset Class Tool to illustrate the huge returns if an investor had managed somehow to foresee the market and had the tactical asset allocation perfectly positioned for each movement in the market over the past decade.

In reality, of course, attempts at trying to time the markets often end badly with potentially big losses for investors.

Cuffe concludes his article with a telling quote from Vanguard's founder Jack Bogle: "Sure, it would be great to get out of the market at the high and back in at the low. But in 55 years in the business, I not only have never met anybody that knew how to do it, I've never met anybody who met anybody that knew how to do it."

There is plenty for investors to think about here including: the benefits of setting and adhering to an appropriate long-term asset allocation, the perils of market-timing and the risks of having an inflated opinion about one's investment abilities.

 

By Robin Bowerman
Smart Investing
Principal & Head of Retail, Vanguard Investments Australia
02 October 2014

 

 

Any advice contained in this website is of a general nature only and does not take into account your circumstances or needs. You must decide if this information is suitable to your personal situation or seek advice.

Rolanda has been my financial adviser for 20 years. I have always found her to be highly intelligent, knowledgeable and professional in her career. Rolanda is accessible at all times and patiently explains terms that I do not fully understand. I can highly recommend Rolanda and it is a pleasure to do so. I do this with the utmost confidence. Marcia Montgomery (Retiree – home duties and ex-clerk with Water Board)
I retired Oct 2012, and seeking Financial Advice for my retirement funds, I decided to have Rolanda look after my financial affairs, and so happy I did. Since my retirement I am extremely comfortable with Rolanda’s advice, experience and strategies and the returns on my investments. Rolanda is my "Breath of Fresh Air" at this stage of my life and she makes herself available 24/7 should you need to talk with her. Steve Hoad (Ground Engineer, Qantas)
In 1997 I left Energy Australia and decided to join Rolanda Adams Financial Services for the financial support and advice that I would need into the future. That decision has proved a very good one and I am still with Rolanda who has given me advice and friendship over those many years. The advice given has ensured that my investments have been protected and the major losses, of some, during the GFC was not felt by me unduly. Rolanda and her team are very easy to contact at any time and one is always received in a most professional manner. I would be most happy to recommend Rolanda Adams Financial Services to all who need financial services. Graham Fleeton (Manager, Property Insurance Group Energy Australia (Ausgrid))
Rolanda has been my Adviser for the past 18 years. Through her wide industry experience and professional expertise she has ensured the sound development and ongoing management of my investments. Her advice has invariably been sound, timely and entirely tuned to meet my personal needs in retirement. She has a friendly, engaging manner and is always readily available to address any of my concerns. I have no hesitation in recommending her. Neil O'Keeffe (Chief Inspector (retired), Australian Customs Service)

© 2020 Rolanda Adams Financial Services Pty Ltd. All rights reserved. Site by PlannerWeb.